Different denominations in the American Protestant
Churches
(Mainline vs.
Evangelical)
In typical usage, the term mainline is contrasted
with evangelical. Theologically
conservative critics accuse the mainline churches of "the substitution
of leftist social action for Christian evangelizing, and the disappearance
of biblical theology," and maintain that "All the Mainline
churches have become essentially the same church: their histories, their
theologies, and even much of their practice lost to a uniform vision of
social progress."
The Association of Religion
Data Archives (ARDA) counts 26,344,933
members of mainline churches versus 39,930,869 members of evangelical
Protestant churches. There is evidence that
there has been a shift in membership from mainline denominations to
evangelical churches.
As shown in the table
below, some denominations with similar names and historical ties to
Evangelical groups are considered Mainline.
|
Protestant: Mainline vs. Evangelical
|
Family:
|
Total:[4]
|
US%[4]
|
Examples:
|
Type:
|
Baptist
|
38,662,005
|
25.3%
|
Southern Baptist Convention
|
Evangelical
|
American Baptist Churches
in the U.S.A.
|
Mainline
|
Pentecostal
|
13,673,149
|
8.9%
|
Assemblies of God
|
Evangelical
|
Lutheran
|
7,860,683
|
5.1%
|
Evangelical Lutheran
Church in America
|
Mainline
|
Lutheran Church, Missouri Synod
|
Evangelical
|
Presbyterian/
Reformed
|
5,844,855
|
3.8%
|
Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.)
|
Mainline
|
Presbyterian Church in America
|
Evangelical
|
Methodist
|
5,473,129
|
3.6%
|
United Methodist Church
|
Mainline
|
African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church
|
Evangelical
|
Anglican
|
2,323,100
|
1.5%
|
Episcopal Church
|
Mainline
|
Adventist
|
2,203,600
|
1.4%
|
Seventh-Day
Adventist Church
|
Evangelical
|
Holiness
|
2,135,602
|
1.4%
|
Church
of the Nazarene
|
Evangelical
|
Other
Groups
|
1,366,678
|
0.9%
|
Church
of the Brethren
|
Evangelical
|
Friends General Conference
|
Mainline
|
|
Evangelicalism
Evangelicalism
is a Protestant Christian movement in which most
adherents consider its key characteristics to be: a belief in the need for
personal conversion (or being "born again"), a high regard for Biblical authority and an emphasis on the death and resurrection of Jesus. David Bebbington has termed
these distinctive aspects conversionism
, activism, biblicism, and crucicentrism.
The
term "Evangelical" does not equal Fundamentalist
Christianity, although the latter is sometimes
regarded simply as the most theologically conservative subset of the
former. The major differences largely hinge upon views of how to regard and
approach scripture ("Theology of Scripture"), as well as construing
its broader world-view implications. While most conservative Evangelicals
believe the label has broadened too
much beyond its more limiting traditional distinctives, this trend is
nonetheless strong enough to create significant ambiguity in the term. As
a result, the dichotomy between "evangelical" vs.
"mainline" denominations is increasingly complex .
The
contemporary North American usage of the term is influenced by the
evangelical/fundamentalist controversy of the early 20th century.
Evangelicalism may sometimes be perceived as the middle ground between the theological liberalism of the Mainline (Protestant) denominations
and the cultural separatism of Fundamentalist
Christianity. Evangelicalism
has therefore been described as "the third of the leading strands in
American Protestantism, straddling the divide between fundamentalists and
liberals."
Evangelicals
held the view that the modernist and liberal parties in the Protestant
churches had surrendered their heritage as Evangelicals by accommodating
the views and values of the world.
At the same time, they criticized their fellow Fundamentalists for their
separatism and their rejection of the Social
Gospel as it had been
developed by Protestant activists of the previous century. They charged the
modernists with having lost their identity as Evangelicals and the
Fundamentalists with having lost the Christ-like heart of Evangelicalism.
They argued that the Gospel needed to be reasserted to distinguish it from
the innovations of the liberals and the fundamentalists.
The
movement's aim at the outset was to reclaim the Evangelical heritage in
their respective churches, not to begin something new; and for this reason,
following their separation from Fundamentalists, the same movement has been
better known merely as "Evangelicalism." By the end of the 20th
century, this was the most influential development in American Protestant
Christianity.
|